James V: Religion and Reform

Chapter 2 : Ecclesiastical Nominations

Earlier Scottish kings had negotiated an eight month period for them to nominate a new Bishop; James pursued his rights in the matter of benefices vigorously, and frequently wrote to Rome complaining if his wishes were not respected.

Leo-X-who-confirmed-James-V’s-right-to-nominate-bishops
Leo X who confirmed James V's right to nominate bishops

The story is complex, but worth telling, as it is a microcosm of how the whole ecclesiastical system was run.

There were five contenders in the race.

Seal-of-Gavin-Douglas-as-Bishop-of-Dunkeld
Seal of Gavin Douglas as Bishop of Dunkeld

Queen Margaret’s secretary described the situation:

‘Every man taks up abbacyis that may .. est: thay tary not quhilk (until) benefices be vacant: thai tak tham or (before) thai fall…’